Competition in Bayern’s Defense: Why Is Tah Now Only a Second-Choice Player?

Jonathan Tah is currently having to adjust to an unfamiliar role at FC Bayern. The German national team player sat on the bench for the entire 2-2 draw against Borussia Dortmund. Instead, interim coach Aaron Danks once again relied on Minjae Kim and Dayot Upamecano in central defense. After the Bundesliga classic, the Englishman commented on the 30-year-old’s current situation.

As recently as last season, Tah was one of the undisputed starters for the German record champions. Together with Upamecano, he formed the preferred center-back duo for much of the season. However, the situation has since changed.

Kim, in particular, has played his way back into the spotlight with consistently strong performances. The South Korean has recently been chosen over Tah on several occasions and was also in the starting lineup for the crucial top-of-the-table clash against Dortmund.

Danks raves about Kim and Upamecano

Even before kickoff, Danks had explained that the decision to start Kim was primarily related to the physical condition of the two center backs. “It’s about freshness. Jonathan has also played recently; we trust every player, and both are in good form. Minjae sat out one game recently—he’s simply fresher,” emphasized Kompany’s deputy.

After the final whistle, the 41-year-old was once again asked about the situation in Munich’s defense.

Danks made it clear that he was very satisfied with the performances of his center backs. “We have three top-class center backs. I thought the two who played today, Minjae Kim and Upamecano, put in a fantastic performance.”

The Englishman particularly highlighted the duo’s performances against Dortmund.

“I thought they had some really, really good moments.”

No demotion for Jonathan Tah

Jonathan Tah
Photo: IMAGO

Despite being benched again, Danks didn’t want to cast any doubt on Tah’s qualities. “And Jonathan Tah has also put in two very good performances recently, so we’re blessed with really good players. And they all seize their moments to perform for us.”

With that, the interim coach made it clear that he continues to rely on all three center backs.

However, a new competitive dynamic is emerging in Munich’s defense. While Upamecano is currently considered a starter, Tah and Kim are battling for the second spot in the center of the defense.

The South Korean has had the upper hand lately. His strong performances have meant that Tah can no longer take his starting spot for granted.

Nevertheless, there is no question of a permanent demotion for the German international. Especially given the tight schedule, both defenders are likely to continue seeing regular playing time.

Bayern Munich’s next important match is already scheduled for Tuesday. In the Champions League, the Munich team will face Atlético Madrid on the road.

For Tah, this could mean another opportunity to earn a spot in the starting lineup in just a few days.

In any case, Danks’ comments show that competition within the Bayern defense is expressly encouraged. For Tah, however, this also means he’ll have to work his way back into his former starting spot.

This article was translated into English by AI. You can read the original version here https://fcbinside.de/2026/11/01/konkurrenzkampf-in-der-bayern-abwehr-warum-ist-tah-nur-noch-zweite-wahl/.
Share This Article