FC Bayern only managed a 1-1 draw against Cologne and will be without Harry Kane for months. Meanwhile, Karl-Heinz Rummenigge has intensified the debate surrounding Jamal Musiala. Three takeaways.
FC Bayern had envisioned Friday night as a fresh start. Vincent Kompany returned to the sidelines, and Jamal Musiala took the field for the first time in about two months. After the final whistle, the main questions are how Munich will manage without Harry Kane for months and why, of all times, Musiala’s salary is once again being discussed publicly.
The two lost points are frustrating. More serious, however, is what the evening means for the coming weeks. Kompany must reshuffle his attack, while a key returnee still needs to regain his rhythm. This evening has the potential to plunge Bayern into a crisis. At least one player stood out against Cologne—someone who’s already stepping up to take responsibility during this difficult phase. FCBinside offers three takeaways from the game:
1. Kane’s absence is changing Bayern’s season
Harry Kane had to leave the field after 20 minutes. The diagnosis came after the game: a torn syndesmotic ligament in his left ankle. The World Player of the Year will be out for several months. Michael Olise also had to leave the game; Bayern diagnosed him with a forefoot contusion. The injury is significantly less serious. It remains unclear when Olise will be able to play again.
For Kompany, this is about much more than just filling the No. 9 spot. Kane is Munich’s top scorer and, at the same time, one of their most important playmakers—and a leader.
When he drops back into midfield, he can accelerate an attack with a pass and then reappear in the penalty area himself. Kompany will likely have to distribute these two roles among several players. Olise can take on some of the creative workload as soon as he’s available again. Who will finish off the crosses in the penalty area remains a separate question.
After tonight’s game, a winter transfer is once again a likely possibility. But there are still seven competitive matches left before the winter break. Kompany needs his first solution by Wednesday’s match against OSC Lille. Squad planning for January and the lineup for Lille are thus two tasks with very different deadlines.
2. Bayern’s bosses are putting pressure on Musiala at an inopportune time
First, honorary president Uli Hoeneß expressed doubts about Musiala’s return to his former form. Now Karl-Heinz Rummenigge has added to the pressure. Bayern’s supervisory board member told Sky that the evidence so far makes a return to his former level seem unlikely. Should Musiala fail to reach that level on a permanent basis, Rummenigge believes it would be appropriate to hold discussions with the player, his family, and his agency regarding his salary. For now, however, the club wants to wait and see how he develops.
The timing is hard to understand. Musiala had just played his first 20 minutes since tearing a muscle fiber. A deflected shot went just wide. With a little luck, he might have scored the game-winning goal on his comeback. From a sporting perspective, this was a first step. Rummenigge’s comments that same evening brought to the forefront the question of whether his salary would one day still match his performance.
It’s part of the job for club officials to internally evaluate whether to offer FC Bayern a long-term, high-paying contract. However, making these considerations public on the evening of his comeback increases the pressure on a player who’s only just started getting playing time again. His next appearance may already be judged by whether the old Musiala is back—and whether he’s “worth” all that money. After a two-month break, what he needs most of all are opportunities to regain his rhythm.
Konrad Laimer defended his teammate: “From everything I’ve seen, I have absolutely no doubt that he’ll return to his former level,” the Austrian said after the game. He attributed this to Musiala’s daily work. For Kompany, this outlook is particularly relevant right now. With Kane out, he’s missing his most important offensive player. Musiala can give the attack more options again if he can gradually increase his playing time.
3. Urbig is Bayern’s bright spot against Cologne
Jonas Urbig secured a point for FC Bayern. He was powerless to stop Mikey Moore’s early 0-1 goal. After the break, he first made a save against Said El Mala and then immediately reacted to Linton Maina’s hard follow-up shot. That double save kept Bayern in the game. In the FCBinside individual player ratings, Urbig was the only Munich player to receive a grade of 1.

In Mainz, Urbig had come into the game after Neuer was substituted and was barely tested. Against Cologne, he got a taste of what’s expected of a Bayern goalkeeper in a tight match: After long stretches with little to do, he has to be immediately on his toes during a quick counterattack. That’s exactly what he did. As long as Manuel Neuer is out—who is currently, surprisingly, in Brazil—Urbig can continue to prove himself over the coming weeks.
Bayern has designated him as the future number one. Against Cologne, he once again demonstrated why the club believes he is up to the task. This could prove decisive, especially in the coming weeks. With Bayern fielding a newly assembled offense and close matches often remaining undecided until the very end, saves like the ones he made against Cologne can mean the difference between a loss, a draw, or a win.

